The best affordable toilets prove that you do not need to spend a fortune to get a reliable flush, a comfortable seat, and an easy-to-clean bowl. Many budget models now include features that used to be found only on expensive toilets, such as dual flush, comfort height, and soft-close seats.
To help you choose, we compared seven popular models from Gerber, HOROW, DeerValley, and American Standard. We judged each one on flushing performance, comfort, water use, included parts, and overall value. Our quick verdict: the Gerber Maxwell Select is the best overall value, the DeerValley DV-2F52531 is the best budget comfort-height model, and the American Standard Cadet PRO Round is the best basic replacement.
Best Affordable Toilets: Top Picks Compared
Our top picks for affordable toilets are the Gerber Maxwell Select Elongated Dual-Flush Toilet, the Gerber Avalanche Select Two-Piece Toilet, and the HOROW T0338W One Piece Toilet ADA Chair.
Pros
- Exceptional flush performance with fast refill, as noted in customer reviews.
- Easy, tool-free installation saves time and frustration.
- Quiet operation and sturdy soft-close seat add comfort and durability.
- Water-efficient dual flush lowers utility costs while maintaining strong flushing power.
- ADA comfort height is ideal for adults and accessible bathrooms.
Cons
- Heavy at 81.9 pounds, may require two people for safe installation.
- Two-piece design has more seams and crevices than a one-piece toilet, which may require extra cleaning effort.
- Some users may prefer a traditional handle over the push-button flush mechanism.
The Gerber Maxwell Select Elongated Two-Piece Dual-Flush Toilet combines water efficiency with powerful performance, making it a smart choice for modern bathrooms. Designed for homes, rental properties, or high-traffic areas, this ADA-compliant comfort height toilet offers easy access and reliable flushing. With a dual-flush system that provides both 1.0 and 1.28 gallons per flush, it helps reduce water usage without compromising on waste removal.
Standout features include the tool-free ReadySet installation kit, which includes a wax ring and all mounting hardware for a fast setup. The soft-close elongated seat prevents slamming and enhances safety, while the smooth glazed trapway and canister flush valve deliver virtually clog-free performance. Customer reviews highlight its quiet operation, fast refill, and sturdy construction, with many praising the easy installation and great value.
Design and build quality are solid, with a durable ceramic bowl and polypropylene seat that feels substantial. The two-piece design fits most standard bathrooms and complements a variety of decors. However, at 81.9 pounds, the toilet is heavy and may require two people to lift and position during installation. Additionally, two-piece toilets have more crevices than one-piece models, which could mean slightly more cleaning effort over time.
Potential drawbacks are minor: the push-button flush may take some getting used to for those accustomed to a handle, and the weight could be a challenge for solo installers. Overall, these are outweighed by the toilet's excellent performance, water savings, and positive user feedback. Most reviewers give it five stars, noting its reliability and ease of use.
Verdict: The Gerber Maxwell Select is a top-tier dual-flush toilet that delivers on its promises of efficiency, comfort, and durability. It is an excellent upgrade for any bathroom, especially for those seeking ADA compliance or water savings. With a near-perfect rating and a price that offers great value, it is highly recommended for homeowners and landlords alike.
Brand: Gerber
Model: GRD49210E
Type: Two-Piece Toilet
Color: White
Shape: Elongated Oval
Dimensions: 28.5 in D x 17.5 in W x 31 in H
Weight: 81.9 lbs
Material: Ceramic bowl, Polypropylene seat
Flush Type: Dual-flush (1.0 and 1.28 GPF)
Installation: Floor mounted, tool-free kit included
Included Components: Toilet bowl, tank, soft-close seat, wax ring, mounting hardware
ADA Compliant: Yes (comfort height)
Pros
- Powerful but water-efficient flush performance
- Tool-free seat installation and removal simplify cleaning
- Stain-resistant KeepClean glaze reduces maintenance
- Comfortable elongated height, popular with older users
- Complete package includes seat, wax ring, and hardware
Cons
- Some users may find the flush louder than expected
- Water supply line not included, and a longer line may be needed due to toilet height
- Heavy ceramic construction requires two people for safe installation
The Gerber Avalanche Select is a two-piece elongated toilet built for homeowners who want a strong flush without excessive noise. It is a versatile choice for both primary and secondary bathrooms, and it includes a soft-close seat and installation hardware in the box.
The QuietClean system uses dual rim jets to circulate water longer, which creates a deeper rinse and a quieter flush. The 1.28 GPF high-efficiency flush is powerful enough to prevent clogs while keeping water use low, according to customer experiences.
The KeepClean glaze is a permanent ultra-smooth surface that helps the bowl resist stains and makes wiping it clean much easier. The ReadySet seat removes without tools in seconds, so cleaning around the seat and bowl is more convenient.
Installation is straightforward thanks to the ReadySet kit and included wax ring, though buyers note the toilet is heavy and may need two people. All necessary parts are included, but you may need a new water supply line if your old one does not reach the taller bowl height.
Most owners praise the comfort height, clean design, and reliable flushing performance. One reviewer found the flush loud, but that was an exception. For a well-priced, low-maintenance toilet with easy installation and a strong warranty, the Gerber Avalanche Select is a smart buy.
Brand: Gerber
Model: GRS48211E
Type: Two-piece elongated toilet
Color: White
Material: Ceramic
Flush Rate: 1.28 GPF
Dimensions: 29.88 in D x 16.5 in W x 31.75 in H
Weight: 91.2 pounds
Seat Material: Polypropylene (PP)
Installation: Floor mounted
Included: Wax ring, mounting hardware, soft-close seat
Pros
- Seamless one-piece design is easy to wipe down and looks modern.
- ADA chair height makes sitting and standing easier for all users.
- Strong siphon flush and dual flush option save water without sacrificing performance.
- Soft-close seat reduces noise and adds convenience.
- Includes all necessary installation hardware, simplifying setup.
Cons
- Installation can be challenging due to heavy weight and limited access to tightening bolts.
- Side access holes for mounting bolts are small, making wrench work difficult.
- Compact tank may require careful alignment with existing plumbing.
The HOROW T0338W is a compact one-piece toilet designed for small bathrooms and users seeking ADA-compliant comfort. Its 17.3 inch seat height makes it easier for seniors and those with mobility challenges to sit and stand.
Standout features include a dual flush system (1.1/1.6 GPF) paired with a fully glazed 2 inch trapway and siphon flushing. This combination delivers powerful waste removal while saving water, and the soft-close seat adds a touch of quiet convenience.
Built from durable ceramic with a sleek, skirted design, the toilet measures 26.6 inches deep by 15 inches wide by 26 inches high. The seamless exterior is easy to clean, though the unit weighs nearly 100 pounds, requiring careful handling during installation.
Some users report that the side access holes for mounting bolts are small, making tightening difficult. The weight also makes centering on the flange tricky, but the included hardware and clear instructions help offset these challenges.
Overall, the HOROW T0338W offers excellent value for its price. It combines space-saving dimensions, accessibility features, and reliable performance, making it a top choice for small bathrooms and users who prioritize comfort and ease of cleaning.
Brand: HOROW
Model: T0338W
Dimensions: 26.6" D x 15" W x 26" H
Weight: 99.2 pounds
Material: Ceramic
Seat Material: Plastic (soft-close)
Flush Type: Siphon, dual flush (1.1/1.6 GPF)
Rough-In: 10 inches or 12 inches (selectable)
Warranty: 1 year limited
Pros
- Comfortable ADA height suitable for elderly or mobility-challenged users
- Efficient flush saves water without sacrificing performance
- Quiet-close seat reduces noise disturbance
- High-quality glaze resists stains and cracks
- Affordable price point for a feature-rich toilet
Cons
- Two-piece design may be slightly harder to install than one-piece models
- Some users report occasional flush noise due to high water pressure
- Seat may not be as durable as higher-end models
The DeerValley DV-2F52531 two-piece toilet is designed for homeowners who value comfort, efficiency, and modern style. With its ADA compliant 17 13/16 inch seat height, it is an excellent choice for elderly individuals, tall users, or anyone with mobility concerns. The elongated bowl provides extra legroom, while the high white finish fits seamlessly into any bathroom decor.
Standout features include a powerful 1.28 GPF flush system that uses a high water level and 360-degree jet spiral scrubbing to remove waste effectively. Despite its low water consumption, the flush delivers strong performance, reducing clogs and the need for double flushing. The quiet-close seat adds a touch of luxury, closing silently without slamming.
Build quality is impressive for the price. The ceramic is fired at high temperatures, resulting in a dense, low-porosity glaze that resists stains, scratches, and cracking. The included soft-closing seat is made of polypropylene and feels sturdy. The two-piece design is standard and straightforward to install, though it may require more effort than a one-piece model.
Potential drawbacks include a slightly louder flush compared to some high-end toilets, which some users may notice at night. The seat, while functional, may not be as plush or durable as premium aftermarket options. Additionally, the toilet is relatively heavy at 90 pounds, so installation may be a two-person job.
Overall, the DeerValley DV-2F52531 offers outstanding value. It combines ADA accessibility, water efficiency, and a quiet-close seat at a price that is hard to beat. For budget-conscious buyers who do not want to compromise on comfort or performance, this toilet is a top recommendation.
Pros
- Compact size ideal for small bathrooms and guest toilets
- Water-saving dual flush with powerful performance
- Skirted design simplifies cleaning significantly
- Soft-close seat included for quiet, comfortable use
- Standard height round bowl fits most users comfortably
Cons
- Round bowl offers less legroom than elongated models
- Heavy at 78 pounds, so installation may require two people
- Fixed 12-inch rough-in may not suit all existing plumbing configurations
The DeerValley Compact One Piece Toilet is a space-saving solution for small bathrooms, half baths, and guest powder rooms. Its round bowl and standard seat height provide a comfortable, ergonomic sitting position while keeping the footprint tight at just under 25 inches deep and 13 inches wide.
Performance is a strong point. The dual flush system offers a 1.1 GPF liquid flush and a 1.6 GPF solid flush, using up to 60 percent less water than older 3.5 GPF models. That can save roughly 16,500 gallons per year, yet the flushing action remains powerful and quiet, making it a smart choice for water-conscious households.
The fully skirted ceramic body is a standout design feature. It eliminates the usual nooks and crevices around the base and trapway, so cleaning is simply a quick wipe. The included soft-close PP seat adds a touch of comfort and operates at just 28dB, preventing noisy slams on late-night trips.
One thing to consider is that the round bowl provides less surface area than an elongated model, and the toilet is fairly heavy at 78 pounds, so installation may require two people. Also, it is designed for a standard 12-inch rough-in, so be sure to measure your existing plumbing before ordering.
Overall, the DeerValley compact one-piece toilet delivers a strong combination of water efficiency, easy maintenance, and space-saving design for the price. With a complete installation kit and a one-year warranty, it is a solid upgrade for smaller bathrooms that still need full-size comfort.
Pros
- Exceptional flushing power with a 4-inch valve and glazed trapway
- Low-maintenance one-piece design with EverClean antimicrobial surface
- Comfortable chair-height seating with slow-close seat included
- Backed by a limited 10-year warranty from American Standard
Cons
- Heavy at 115 pounds, may require two people for installation
- Some users may find the elongated shape too long for smaller bathrooms
- Included seat is plastic, not as premium as wood or cushioned options
The American Standard Champion 4 is a one-piece elongated toilet engineered for demanding households. With a 4-inch flush valve and a 2-3/8-inch fully glazed trapway, this model promises powerful, clog-free performance. It is designed for anyone who prioritizes reliability and easy maintenance in a bathroom fixture.
The toilet features a chair-height bowl at 16.5 inches, which makes sitting and standing significantly easier. This is especially beneficial for older adults, taller individuals, or anyone with mobility concerns. The elongated shape also provides a more spacious interior surface for enhanced comfort.
Build quality is solid, with a seamless one-piece construction in durable vitreous china. The EverClean surface helps inhibit stains and odor-causing bacteria, reducing the frequency of deep cleaning. A slow-close toilet seat and chrome trip lever are included, so no extra purchases are necessary.
Potential drawbacks include the toilet's substantial weight, which can make installation a two-person job. The included seat is plastic, which may not appeal to those wanting a softer or more premium feel. Also, the elongated footprint may not suit very compact powder rooms, so measuring your space is advised.
Overall, the American Standard Champion 4 delivers outstanding flushing power and low-maintenance operation in a comfortable, accessible package. Its 10-year limited warranty provides added peace of mind. For homeowners seeking a reliable, easy-to-clean toilet, this model is a strong contender.
What to Expect from Affordable Toilets
Affordable toilets usually have simpler designs, fewer premium finishes, and sometimes louder flushes than high-end models. However, the best budget toilets still flush reliably and meet current water standards. You can save money without accepting poor performance if you focus on the features that matter most.
How to Choose the Best Affordable Toilets
Choosing the right affordable toilets comes down to flushing performance, water efficiency, comfort height, and included parts.
- Flushing Performance: A strong flush prevents clogs and saves you from frequent plunging. The American Standard Champion 4 uses a large 4-inch flush valve for clog-free performance, and the Gerber Avalanche Select delivers a powerful 1.28 GPF flush.
- Water Efficiency: Look for WaterSense-certified or dual-flush models. They reduce water bills, which makes an affordable toilet even cheaper to own over time. The HOROW T0338W and DeerValley Compact both use dual-flush systems.
- Comfort Height: Comfort-height models are about 17 to 19 inches tall. The Gerber Maxwell Select, HOROW T0338W, and DeerValley DV-2F52531 all offer ADA height at a budget-friendly price.
- Included Parts: Some budget toilets include a seat, a wax ring, and bolts, while others do not. A complete package, such as the Gerber Maxwell Select with its soft-close seat, saves money and time.
- One-Piece or Two-Piece: Two-piece toilets are usually the cheapest. One-piece models, such as the HOROW and DeerValley Compact, cost a little more but are easier to clean.
Tips for Saving Money on a New Toilet
- Measure the rough-in first so that you buy the right model the first time.
- Choose a model that includes a seat if you do not already have one.
- Install it yourself if you are comfortable with basic plumbing.
- Look for local water utility rebates on WaterSense toilets.
If you need a compact model, read our guide to the best toilet for a small bathroom. For premium options, see our main guide to the best toilets.
Installation Tips
Measure the rough-in distance, which is the space from the finished wall to the center of the drain flange. Most toilets use a 12-inch rough-in, but some homes have 10 or 14 inches. Replace the wax ring or use a wax-free seal when installing a new toilet, and tighten floor bolts evenly to avoid cracking the base.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Do not buy without checking rough-in and bowl shape. Avoid overtightening bolts, and compare flush ratings and seat height when choosing between affordable toilets.
Final Verdict on the Best Affordable Toilets
After comparing these models, we recommend the Gerber Maxwell Select as the best affordable toilet overall. It offers a strong dual flush, ADA height, a soft-close seat, and tool-free installation. If you want comfort height at a lower price, the DeerValley DV-2F52531 includes a quiet-close seat and a 1.28 GPF flush. If you only need a simple, dependable replacement, the American Standard Cadet PRO Round is a proven choice from a trusted brand.
Affordable Toilets FAQs
Common questions from buyers include “Are cheap toilets worth buying?”, “How much should I spend on a toilet?”, and “Do affordable toilets clog more often?”.
Are cheap toilets worth buying?
Many affordable toilets work well for years. Choose a model with good reviews, a reliable flush, and a well-known brand or warranty.
How much should I spend on a toilet?
Many good toilets cost between $200 and $400. Premium models with special features can cost much more.
Do affordable toilets clog more often?
Not necessarily. Many budget models flush very well. Check the flush valve size, reviews, and MaP score when available.
Can I install a toilet myself to save money?
Yes. Most toilets can be installed with basic tools in a few hours, and some models offer tool-free installation.
Is a two-piece toilet cheaper than a one-piece?
Usually, yes. Two-piece toilets cost less to make and ship, so they are often the most affordable option.
For more bathroom ideas, browse our best toilets category.
Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!