The best toilets flush powerfully, save water, and stay comfortable for every member of the household. Modern models use far less water than older ones, yet the best designs clear the bowl in a single flush. Choosing the right model also means thinking about seat height, bowl shape, and how easy it is to clean.
To help you choose, we compared eight popular models from Gerber, HOROW, Simple Project, Casta Diva, DeerValley, and TOTO. We judged each model on flushing performance, water use, comfort, installation, and cleaning. Our quick verdict: the Gerber Maxwell Select Dual-Flush Toilet is the best overall pick, the TOTO Drake Two-Piece Toilet is the best choice for powerful, low-maintenance flushing, and the Simple Project 21 Inch Tall Toilet is the best option for seniors and tall users.
Best Toilets: Top Picks Compared
Our top pick is the TOTO Drake Two-Piece Elongated 1.6 GPF Universal.
Pros
- Exceptional flush performance with fast refill, as noted in customer reviews.
- Easy, tool-free installation saves time and frustration.
- Quiet operation and sturdy soft-close seat add comfort and durability.
- Water-efficient dual flush lowers utility costs while maintaining strong flushing power.
- ADA comfort height is ideal for adults and accessible bathrooms.
Cons
- Heavy at 81.9 pounds, may require two people for safe installation.
- Two-piece design has more seams and crevices than a one-piece toilet, which may require extra cleaning effort.
- Some users may prefer a traditional handle over the push-button flush mechanism.
The Gerber Maxwell Select Elongated Two-Piece Dual-Flush Toilet combines water efficiency with powerful performance, making it a smart choice for modern bathrooms. Designed for homes, rental properties, or high-traffic areas, this ADA-compliant comfort height toilet offers easy access and reliable flushing. With a dual-flush system that provides both 1.0 and 1.28 gallons per flush, it helps reduce water usage without compromising on waste removal.
Standout features include the tool-free ReadySet installation kit, which includes a wax ring and all mounting hardware for a fast setup. The soft-close elongated seat prevents slamming and enhances safety, while the smooth glazed trapway and canister flush valve deliver virtually clog-free performance. Customer reviews highlight its quiet operation, fast refill, and sturdy construction, with many praising the easy installation and great value.
Design and build quality are solid, with a durable ceramic bowl and polypropylene seat that feels substantial. The two-piece design fits most standard bathrooms and complements a variety of decors. However, at 81.9 pounds, the toilet is heavy and may require two people to lift and position during installation. Additionally, two-piece toilets have more crevices than one-piece models, which could mean slightly more cleaning effort over time.
Potential drawbacks are minor: the push-button flush may take some getting used to for those accustomed to a handle, and the weight could be a challenge for solo installers. Overall, these are outweighed by the toilet's excellent performance, water savings, and positive user feedback. Most reviewers give it five stars, noting its reliability and ease of use.
Verdict: The Gerber Maxwell Select is a top-tier dual-flush toilet that delivers on its promises of efficiency, comfort, and durability. It is an excellent upgrade for any bathroom, especially for those seeking ADA compliance or water savings. With a near-perfect rating and a price that offers great value, it is highly recommended for homeowners and landlords alike.
Brand: Gerber
Model: GRD49210E
Type: Two-Piece Toilet
Color: White
Shape: Elongated Oval
Dimensions: 28.5 in D x 17.5 in W x 31 in H
Weight: 81.9 lbs
Material: Ceramic bowl, Polypropylene seat
Flush Type: Dual-flush (1.0 and 1.28 GPF)
Installation: Floor mounted, tool-free kit included
Included Components: Toilet bowl, tank, soft-close seat, wax ring, mounting hardware
ADA Compliant: Yes (comfort height)
Pros
- Easy installation with all necessary parts included, plus a standard kit for flange compatibility.
- Fast, powerful flush that clears the bowl completely without using excess water.
- Soft-close seat prevents noise and is safer for kids and seniors.
- Sleek, modern design that fits both primary and secondary bathrooms.
- High customer rating with many reviewers praising build quality and performance.
Cons
- Weighs nearly 80 pounds, so two people may be needed for lifting and positioning during installation.
- Single flush volume only; some may prefer a dual-flush option for more water savings.
- As with any porcelain fixture, shipping damage can occur if handled improperly, though Amazon's replacement policy covers such issues.
The Gerber Maxwell Crest Elongated Two-Piece Toilet is a high-efficiency, ADA-compliant fixture designed for modern bathrooms. It is ideal for homeowners and DIY enthusiasts who want a dependable, water-saving toilet that is easy to install and built to last.
At the heart of this toilet is a powerful 1.28 GPF flush system that clears the bowl efficiently without wasting water. The 3-inch flush valve and Fluidmaster fill valve work together to provide a fast, quiet refill and a strong, virtually clog-free flush. Reviewers note that the flush is surprisingly forceful and leaves the bowl clean with a single press.
The build quality is excellent, featuring durable vitreous china that resists scratches and stains. The elongated bowl offers added comfort, and the included soft-close seat is a thoughtful touch that reduces noise and prevents slamming. Installation is made simple with the ReadySet kit, which includes aligning tabs, a wax ring, and all necessary hardware. The instruction manual is clear, and many users report completing the setup in under an hour.
One drawback is the toilet's weight (79.4 pounds), which may require two people to lift and position, especially if you are replacing an existing unit. Additionally, this model offers a single flush volume rather than a dual-flush option, which could be a consideration for those seeking maximum water savings. However, the 1.28 GPF rating already exceeds federal standards and performs admirably.
Overall, the Gerber Maxwell Crest delivers exceptional value, combining performance, comfort, and ease of installation at a competitive price. With glowing customer reviews and a brand trusted by plumbers for decades, this toilet is a smart investment for any bathroom renovation.
Brand: Gerber
Model: GRS48310
Product Type: Two-Piece Toilet
Color: White
Shape: Oval (Elongated)
Dimensions (D x W x H): 28.5 x 17.13 x 31 inches
Weight: 79.4 pounds
Flush Type: Single Flush, 1.28 GPF
Material: Vitreous China
Seat Material: Polypropylene (PP)
Installation Method: Floor Mounted
Included Components: Bowl, Tank with Cover, Soft-Close Seat, Wax Ring, Mounting Hardware
Pros
- Seamless one-piece design is easy to wipe down and looks modern.
- ADA chair height makes sitting and standing easier for all users.
- Strong siphon flush and dual flush option save water without sacrificing performance.
- Soft-close seat reduces noise and adds convenience.
- Includes all necessary installation hardware, simplifying setup.
Cons
- Installation can be challenging due to heavy weight and limited access to tightening bolts.
- Side access holes for mounting bolts are small, making wrench work difficult.
- Compact tank may require careful alignment with existing plumbing.
The HOROW T0338W is a compact one-piece toilet designed for small bathrooms and users seeking ADA-compliant comfort. Its 17.3 inch seat height makes it easier for seniors and those with mobility challenges to sit and stand.
Standout features include a dual flush system (1.1/1.6 GPF) paired with a fully glazed 2 inch trapway and siphon flushing. This combination delivers powerful waste removal while saving water, and the soft-close seat adds a touch of quiet convenience.
Built from durable ceramic with a sleek, skirted design, the toilet measures 26.6 inches deep by 15 inches wide by 26 inches high. The seamless exterior is easy to clean, though the unit weighs nearly 100 pounds, requiring careful handling during installation.
Some users report that the side access holes for mounting bolts are small, making tightening difficult. The weight also makes centering on the flange tricky, but the included hardware and clear instructions help offset these challenges.
Overall, the HOROW T0338W offers excellent value for its price. It combines space-saving dimensions, accessibility features, and reliable performance, making it a top choice for small bathrooms and users who prioritize comfort and ease of cleaning.
Brand: HOROW
Model: T0338W
Dimensions: 26.6" D x 15" W x 26" H
Weight: 99.2 pounds
Material: Ceramic
Seat Material: Plastic (soft-close)
Flush Type: Siphon, dual flush (1.1/1.6 GPF)
Rough-In: 10 inches or 12 inches (selectable)
Warranty: 1 year limited
Pros
- Extra-tall 21-inch seat height aids accessibility.
- Soft-close seat prevents noise and wear.
- Efficient 1.28 GPF flush saves water.
- Easy to install with standard rough-in.
- Backed by 2-year warranty and responsive support.
Cons
- At 94 pounds, the toilet is heavy and may require assistance for installation.
- The plastic seat, while durable, may not have the premium feel of wood or cushioned seats.
- Two-piece design may require more cleaning around the seam compared to one-piece toilets.
The Simple Project 21 Inch Tall Toilet is designed specifically for seniors and tall individuals who need extra height for comfortable use. With a seat height of 21 inches, it exceeds standard toilet heights and meets ADA recommendations, making it easier to sit down and stand up without strain.
This toilet features a soft-close elongated seat that eliminates noisy slamming, a common annoyance in busy bathrooms. Its single-flush system uses just 1.28 gallons per flush while achieving a MAP 1000-gram waste removal rating, ensuring powerful and efficient flushing every time.
Crafted from durable ceramic, the toilet is built to last and easy to clean. The two-piece design allows for straightforward installation in standard 12-inch rough-in bathrooms. At 35 inches tall overall, it fits well in most residential spaces while providing ample legroom.
One potential drawback is the weight: at 94 pounds, moving and installing the toilet may require two people. Additionally, the included plastic seat, while functional, may not offer the same comfort as thicker padded options. However, these are minor trade-offs for the accessibility benefits.
Overall, the Simple Project 21 Inch Tall Toilet is an excellent choice for anyone needing a higher toilet. It combines comfort, efficiency, and durability at a reasonable price point. Backed by a 2-year warranty and responsive customer support, it offers great value for seniors, tall users, and those with mobility issues.
Brand: Simple Project
Model: HT-140
Seat Height: 21 inches
Overall Dimensions: 27.9 in D x 14.3 in W x 35 in H
Weight: 94 pounds
Material: Ceramic
Seat Material: Plastic
Flush Type: Single Flush, 1.28 GPF
Rough-In: 12 inches
Color: White
Shape: Elongated
Installation: Floor Mounted
Warranty: 2 years
Pros
- Powerful flush without needing electricity, ideal for renovations or backup use
- Hygienic hands-free operation with foot kick and side button options
- Comfort height seat (17.2 inches) reduces strain for elderly or tall users
- Quiet-close seat prevents slamming and adds convenience
- Easy to install with all necessary hardware included
Cons
- Requires a 12 inch rough-in, which may not fit all existing bathroom setups
- Air-pressure assisted flush can be louder than traditional gravity flush toilets
- Only available in white, limiting color options for some decors
The Casta Diva Elongated One Piece Toilet offers a unique blend of hands-free convenience and powerful flushing technology, making it a standout choice for modern bathrooms. Designed for those who prioritize hygiene and accessibility, this toilet is especially suited for seniors, individuals with mobility issues, or anyone looking to reduce contact with high-touch surfaces.
Its standout feature is the air-pressure assisted flush system, which delivers a robust 1.0 GPF flush without relying on electricity. This system works effectively even in low water pressure environments, ensuring consistent performance. The foot kick and side button flush options allow you to flush without touching a handle, a significant advantage for cleanliness and ease of use.
The toilet boasts a sleek, skirted design with a quiet-close seat and a 17.2 inch ADA compliant comfort height. The elongated bowl provides extra room, and the vitreous china construction resists stains and scratches. Installation is straightforward thanks to the standard 12 inch rough-in and included mounting kit.
Potential drawbacks include the need for a specific rough-in size (12 inches), which may not match all existing plumbing. The air-pressure flush can be noisier than a gravity model, though many users find the trade-off acceptable for the performance. Additionally, the toilet is only available in white.
Overall, the Casta Diva one-piece toilet delivers on its promises of hygiene, accessibility, and water efficiency. It is a solid investment for anyone seeking a reliable, low-maintenance toilet that caters to comfort and modern convenience.
Pros
- Sleek, modern one-piece design with easy-to-clean skirted profile
- Comfortable 17-inch ADA chair height for easier use
- Powerful 1000-gram MAP flush that is quiet and efficient
- Dual flush saves water without compromising performance
- Soft-close seat adds convenience and reduces noise
Cons
- Some users report occasional clogging, particularly with paper, requiring extra water to flush
- Installation may be trickier than traditional two-piece toilets due to the compact one-piece design
- Compact dimensions may not suit larger bathrooms or users who prefer a more spacious bowl
The Casta Diva Elongated One Piece Toilet (model CD-T005) is a modern, skirted toilet designed for homeowners who value both style and efficiency. With its 17-inch ADA comfort chair height, it is an excellent choice for adults, seniors, and anyone seeking easier access and a more natural sitting position. The dual flush system offers water savings without sacrificing power, making it a practical upgrade for any bathroom.
At the heart of this toilet is a powerful siphon jet flush with a MAP rating of 1000 grams. Real-world user reviews highlight that it clears waste effectively and operates quietly, with many appreciating the noise reduction during nighttime use. The dual flush buttons allow you to select 1.1 GPF for liquid waste or 1.6 GPF for solids, earning it EPA WaterSense certification. However, a notable minority of users have experienced clogging issues, particularly with toilet paper, which can require adding extra water to initiate a proper flush.
The one-piece, skirted design is a standout feature: it eliminates the gap between the tank and bowl, creating a seamless profile that is much easier to clean than traditional two-piece toilets. The soft-close seat with quick-release functionality adds everyday convenience and allows for easy removal during cleaning. The compact dimensions (27.17" D x 14.37" W x 25.39" H) help it fit well in smaller bathrooms, though some may find the bowl a bit shorter than standard elongated models.
Build quality is solid, with a glossy ceramic finish that resists staining and scratches. The toilet meets CUPC standards and comes with a one-year limited warranty and lifetime technical support. Installation is designed for a standard 12-inch rough-in and includes all necessary hardware, but some DIYers report that the one-piece design is slightly heavier and more awkward to maneuver than a two-piece unit, so having an extra pair of hands is recommended.
Overall, the Casta Diva Elongated One Piece Toilet offers an excellent balance of modern aesthetics, water efficiency, and comfort at a competitive price. While minor clogging concerns exist, the vast majority of reviews praise its performance, ease of cleaning, and quiet operation. It is a strong choice for anyone looking to upgrade their bathroom with a stylish, high-functioning toilet.
Pros
- Compact size ideal for small bathrooms and guest toilets
- Water-saving dual flush with powerful performance
- Skirted design simplifies cleaning significantly
- Soft-close seat included for quiet, comfortable use
- Standard height round bowl fits most users comfortably
Cons
- Round bowl offers less legroom than elongated models
- Heavy at 78 pounds, so installation may require two people
- Fixed 12-inch rough-in may not suit all existing plumbing configurations
The DeerValley Compact One Piece Toilet is a space-saving solution for small bathrooms, half baths, and guest powder rooms. Its round bowl and standard seat height provide a comfortable, ergonomic sitting position while keeping the footprint tight at just under 25 inches deep and 13 inches wide.
Performance is a strong point. The dual flush system offers a 1.1 GPF liquid flush and a 1.6 GPF solid flush, using up to 60 percent less water than older 3.5 GPF models. That can save roughly 16,500 gallons per year, yet the flushing action remains powerful and quiet, making it a smart choice for water-conscious households.
The fully skirted ceramic body is a standout design feature. It eliminates the usual nooks and crevices around the base and trapway, so cleaning is simply a quick wipe. The included soft-close PP seat adds a touch of comfort and operates at just 28dB, preventing noisy slams on late-night trips.
One thing to consider is that the round bowl provides less surface area than an elongated model, and the toilet is fairly heavy at 78 pounds, so installation may require two people. Also, it is designed for a standard 12-inch rough-in, so be sure to measure your existing plumbing before ordering.
Overall, the DeerValley compact one-piece toilet delivers a strong combination of water efficiency, easy maintenance, and space-saving design for the price. With a complete installation kit and a one-year warranty, it is a solid upgrade for smaller bathrooms that still need full-size comfort.
Pros
- Exceptional flush power with Tornado Flush technology reduces clogs and cleaning frequency.
- CEFIONTECT glaze keeps the bowl cleaner for longer, saving time and water.
- Universal Height and elongated shape provide superior comfort, especially for taller users and those with mobility concerns.
- Water-efficient 1.6 GPF meets modern conservation standards while maintaining strong performance.
- High customer satisfaction with 4.3 out of 5 stars from over 1,000 reviews and ranked #1 in Two-Piece Toilets.
Cons
- Toilet seat, wax ring, flange bolts, and water supply line are not included, requiring additional purchases.
- Heavy at 94 pounds, making installation a two-person job or requiring extra care during setup.
- The included plastic seat material may feel less premium; many users opt for a separate soft-close seat.
The TOTO Drake Two-Piece Elongated 1.6 GPF Universal Height Toilet (model CST776CSFG#01) is a high-performance fixture designed for homeowners who value efficiency and comfort. It features TOTO's renowned Tornado Flush system, which uses dual nozzles to create a powerful centrifugal rinse that cleans the entire bowl without relying on traditional rim holes. This design, combined with the CEFIONTECT glaze, significantly reduces waste sticking and keeps the toilet cleaner with less effort.
In real-world use, the Drake delivers reliable one-flush performance even with the water-saving 1.6 gallons per flush. The 3-inch flush valve and siphon jet bowl ensure strong waste removal, while the Universal Height (ADA compliant) makes it easier for people of all ages to sit and stand. The elongated bowl adds extra comfort, and the Cotton White finish blends seamlessly into any bathroom style.
Build quality is excellent, as expected from TOTO. The ceramic is thick and durable, and the CEFIONTECT coating feels smooth to the touch. The two-piece design simplifies transportation and installation, though the toilet is heavy at 94 pounds. Note that the seat is not included; you will need to purchase a compatible seat separately, which is common for this category.
Potential drawbacks include the need for additional parts (wax ring, bolts, supply line) and the plastic seat material if you opt for the basic included option. Also, the left-hand trip lever may not suit everyone's preference, but it is a standard configuration for many TOTO models. Overall, the Drake offers a strong balance of performance, water savings, and comfort.
Verdict: The TOTO Drake CST776CSFG#01 is an excellent choice for those seeking a reliable, water-efficient toilet with advanced cleaning technology. It is particularly suited for families, taller individuals, and anyone wanting to reduce bathroom maintenance. With its high ratings and top ranking among two-piece toilets, it is a smart investment for a long-lasting, comfortable bathroom fixture.
How to Choose the Best Toilets
A new model should last for many years, so it is worth comparing a few key features before you buy. Use the six factors below to narrow your choices.
- Flushing Performance: Flushing power is the most important feature. Look for a model that clears waste in one flush without frequent clogs. The TOTO Drake uses a Tornado Flush system that swirls water around the bowl, and some Casta Diva models use an air-pressure assisted flush. Gerber Maxwell models deliver strong performance at 1.28 gallons per flush (GPF).
- Water Efficiency: Federal rules limit new models to 1.6 GPF, and WaterSense-certified models use 1.28 GPF or less. Dual-flush designs go further by offering a light flush for liquid waste and a full flush for solids. The Casta Diva 17-inch model, for example, uses 1.1 or 1.6 GPF. Over a year, an efficient model can save thousands of gallons of water.
- One-Piece vs. Two-Piece: A one-piece model has the tank and bowl molded together, so it looks sleek and has fewer crevices to clean. The HOROW T0338W, Casta Diva, and DeerValley are one-piece designs. A two-piece model, like the TOTO Drake and Gerber Maxwell Crest, is usually less expensive, easier to carry, and simpler to repair.
- Seat Height: Standard models are about 15 inches tall. Comfort-height or ADA-compliant models are 17 to 19 inches tall, which makes sitting down and standing up easier for adults, seniors, and people with knee or back problems. The HOROW, Casta Diva, Gerber, and TOTO models offer comfort height, and the Simple Project model goes even taller at 21 inches.
- Bowl Shape and Size: Elongated bowls are about two inches longer than round bowls and feel more comfortable for most adults. Round bowls take up less space, so they suit small bathrooms. The DeerValley Compact uses a round bowl and a space-saving footprint. Before you buy, measure the rough-in, which is the distance from the wall to the center of the floor drain. Most models require a 12-inch rough-in.
- Cleaning and Extra Features: Glazed trapways, skirted bases, and stain-resistant coatings make cleaning much easier. The TOTO Drake uses CEFIONTECT glaze to prevent buildup. Soft-close seats, hands-free flush buttons, and tool-free installation are helpful extras. The Gerber Maxwell models and the foot-kick Casta Diva model offer some of these conveniences.
Choosing by Bathroom Type
- Small bathroom: choose a compact one-piece model with a round bowl, such as the DeerValley.
- Family bathroom: choose a powerful, easy-to-clean model, such as the TOTO Drake or Gerber Maxwell Select.
- Senior or accessible bathroom: choose an ADA-height or tall model, such as the Simple Project 21-inch model.
- Modern bathroom: choose a sleek one-piece model, such as the HOROW or Casta Diva.
If you want to add a wash function to your current setup, read our guide to the best bidet toilet seats. For a tight space, see our picks for the best toilet for a small bathroom.
Start by measuring the rough-in, the distance from the wall to the center of the drain bolts, because most homes use a 12-inch rough-in. Then choose between round and elongated bowls, and between standard and comfort height, which is easier for taller people and older adults. Compare flush performance, water use per flush, and how easy the bowl is to clean.
Finally, check the warranty and parts availability, since flappers, fill valves, and seats wear out over time.
Final Verdict on the Best Toilets
After comparing these models, we recommend the Gerber Maxwell Select Elongated Dual-Flush Toilet as the best overall choice. It combines strong flushing, comfortable ADA height, a soft-close seat, and tool-free installation. If you want proven flushing power and a stain-resistant bowl, the TOTO Drake is one of the most reliable models you can buy. If you need extra height, the Simple Project 21 Inch Tall Toilets is an excellent choice for seniors and tall users.
Toilets FAQs
Common questions from buyers include “What are the best toilets for flushing power?”, “Are one-piece toilets better than two-piece models?”, and “What is a comfort-height toilets?”.
What are the best toilets for flushing power?
Models with a large flush valve, a fully glazed trapway, or a pressure-assisted system usually flush best. The TOTO Drake and Gerber Maxwell models are strong performers.
Are one-piece toilets better than two-piece models?
One-piece designs are easier to clean and look more modern. Two-piece designs are usually cheaper and easier to move and repair. Both types can flush equally well.
What is a comfort-height toilets?
A comfort-height model has a seat about 17 to 19 inches above the floor, which is similar to a chair. It is easier to use for most adults, seniors, and people with mobility issues.
How long do toilets last?
The porcelain bowl and tank can last for decades. Internal parts, such as the flapper and fill valve, usually need replacement every five to ten years.
Can I install a toilets myself?
Yes, if you are comfortable with basic plumbing. Many modern models, including the Gerber Maxwell models, offer tool-free installation. Always check the rough-in measurement before you buy.
For more bathroom upgrades, see our guides to the best toilet plunger and the best replacement toilet seats.
Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!